The patient indicts the claim of hospital to stay the disconnected needle of surgery and ache in the tooth for half a year 5 ten thousand yuan

The patient indicts the claim of hospital to stay the disconnected needle of surgery and ache in the tooth for half a year 5 ten thousand yuan
Will it be May 6 2007, 40 -year-old pair, man of Meishan, their reason one tooth pain get the intersection of Leshan and the intersection of city and the intersection of the People's Hospital and the intersection of stomatology department and treatment, inflammation is depended on half a year later, also find the needle used for operation broke and lost one to cut inside his teeth. Fu Zheng one pleadings lodge a complaint against hospital, request, compensate for medical fee, follow-up treat fee, delay work fee, spirit conciliate fee the intersection of total and 5 over yuan Wan. Yesterday, the school said, the court had already placed on file, everything was subject to judgement of the court.
It is difficult for pain not to bear on the tooth finding, breaking stitching
On the 19th, Fu Zheng told reporter about his experience.
On May 6, 2007, its reason of Fu Zheng of the east slope district of Meishan city lives in home " L Grind one's teeth pain and bite the thing to pain under the left " ,Getting to stomatology department of the People's Hospital of Leshan and making a diagnosis and giving treatment and treating at that time, he hung number of bright some experts of associate professor specially while going to a doctor.
According to the records of case history materials of the hospital, " The intersection of patient and Fu Zheng their check, see, suffer from tooth, knock, hit, ache when the visit for the first time, turn on smelling and stink behind the marrow. The tooth slice shows and suffers from the suspicious alveolar bone of branching place of root of the tooth to absorb slightly, the root sharp Zhou Yan " ,Hospital suffer from tooth, turn on marrow, pull out marrow, put antibacterial paste and cotton ball, punish to it the same day.
Later, it successively replied and examined Fu Zheng to the clinic of the hospital 6 times, mainly cleared up, prepared and sterilized the root tube. Will it be July 15 the same year, Fu Zheng it reach the intersection of hospital and subsequent visit carry on the intersection of root and tube fill with again, doctor suffer from the tooth, shoot the intersection of tooth and block to their fill with.
Fu Zheng says, since pack the root tube, his trouble tooth has had uncomfortable senses all the time in it, and aggravate gradually . He reaches the subsequent visit of the hospital again on November 15, 2007, " L See grind one's teeth the intersection of cheek and the intersection of side and fistula under the left, X slice show root branching and root sharp inflammation obvious, the branching of root has not been exposed " ,Hospital sharp to scratch, blow skill in down root in local anaesthesia.
" After treatment of half a year, my trouble tooth has presented the serious damage consequence. " L Fu Zheng says, on December 5 of the same year, he reached market the People's Hospital of Meishan (former Meishan city second the People's Hospital) in it Go to a doctor, check " L See grind one's teeth the intersection of cheek and the intersection of side and fistula, knock and hit aching (+++) ,The tooth one shows there is a light spot in the tongue lateral root tube " ," R Break the needle " L Image. On the 11th and the 19th of December of the same year, Fu Zheng successively went to the west stomatological hospital of China of university of Sichuan to go to a doctor twice, X one slice of suggestions while treating " L Exist apparatus separate perhaps, marrow the intersection of room and bottom know how things stand and feel confident, pierce through, root the intersection of branching and below has alveolar bones that is absorbed, hit the alveolar bone angle of root to absorb to one in the root far " ,Treat Chinese medicine and grow and tell Fu Zheng it " L It is not good to suffer from the tooth prognosis " . Pair it reach the intersection of Meishan and the intersection of city and the People's Hospital it carries on a subsequent one to be conservative to treat, deal with later.
" An associate professor whom I selected while registering, but that treated me is not she herself, but was made a diagnosis and given treatment for me by another practice men doctor. " Fu Zheng it say he enter behind the consulting room first day, give doctor that he diagnose and treat for being little, the older one is women, the one a bit younger is men, behind two people finish seeing his teeth together, that male doctor opened marrow to treat for him, later was treated and operated by this man doctor to all of November 15, 2007, and write the case history and record the treatment, it is bright some to sign.
Characterize as the moderate breeze malpractice
" Because teeth suffer from inflammation for a long time, the peculiar smell of oral cavity is serious, the ones that bring for my life, work, communication are painful and awkward. " Fu Zheng says, for this tooth, he successively went to the medical matters place of the hospital to consult for several times in it, and reproach hospital by way of written material three times. Hospital three answer in writing successively, think hospital correct for patient to suffer from the diagnosis of the tooth, therapeutic method is apt, there is no unlawful practice, " L Break the needle " R And " L The marrow punches at bottom " It is one of the common complications in the tube treatment of the root, " This case is not a malpractice. "
Fu Zheng thinks, the hospital exists while he suffers from the tooth to treat " L Break the needle " , " The marrow punches at bottom " ," L The root is filled and has not filled out, owed and filled out " And if you can't fulfil, tell by negligent acts medicals such as obligation,etc. in time relevantly, it cause it not to be getting in inflammatory more state for a long time and " L The tooth shuts the bottom of surface to wear, it is unable to remove that the marrow dies, the bone of tooth is absorbed " R When damaging the consequence, unable to take out and break the needle after fetching the needle procedure, December 11, 2008, Fu Zheng one pleadings lodge a complaint against the People's Hospital, Leshan, claim 5 pluralism Wan from hospital.
On March 19 of 2009, the medical association of Leshan entrusted by district people's court in Leshan will draw a conclusion: This case is a medical accident of moderate breeze, the hospital bears slight responsibility.
" All no results till now, I rush about for this tooth. " Fu Zheng said in it, if the thing can not be solved again, he would adopt the extreme method, suffer from this the tooth to pull out and decompose to collect evidence, but all consequences and damages will be undertaken by the hospital.
The hospital takes a stand : All listen to court's judgement
In the morning of the 19th, complain that accepting Yang JinJun, associate professor of treatment of office, says in the People's Hospital, Leshan, the attitude to this of the hospital is very clear, should be born and born in accordance with the rule in accordance with the law according to the medical crash handling regulations, " Hospital believe, appraise result totally, can believe the court just judgement too. "
Right " L That handled Fu Zheng's disease one practised the man doctor " R Statement,Yang JinJun say," L This course of seeing the doctor, the doctor leads the intern to allow. " L Yang JinJun says, " R The doctor in charge is a famous dentistry expert, after this happens, her psychological pressure is very great. " He emphasizes, bright some behaviors of doctor in charge are the operation behavior, all responsibility produced is undertaken by the hospital.
Deal with its desire put forward " L Have tooth pulled out and test the needle " R Statement,say JinJun Yang, in this right of patient, admit hospital already " L Break the needle " R Fact,last needle with any meanings actual," L Hospital this the negative responsibility know prevarication never, but unreasonable requirement sure not to answer in hospital. The medical dispute increases now, it is the only method that only the legal route leaves. " This newspaper will continue paying close attention to progress of this. (Chengdu Business Yang XingQun )
|